Decoding Haryana: Can Cong defy anti-incumbency wave



Amitabh Shukla / Chandigarh

Haryana has been a Congress bastion for the last 10 years and both in 2004 and 2009 when the party formed government at the Centre, the state proved to be the proverbial key to New Delhi. While the party won all 10 seats in 2004, it got an impressive nine seats in the 2009 polls.

Ten years of anti-incumbency, both at the Centre as well as the state, has taken a heavy toll and Congress looks weary and jaded in the state, finding it difficult to handle the onslaught of the BJP driven by its Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi. BJP has traditionally been weak in the land where Arya Samaj had a great influence and still dominates the socio-religious consciousness of the people. The party has always preferred to go into alliance with a regional player due to its limited presence in the rural area. This time, it is in alliance with the Kuldeep Bishnoi led Haryana Janhit Congress.

Main Opposition Indian National Lok Dal is facing an identity crisis with two of its top leaders—the father-son duo of Om Prakash Chautala and Ajay Chautala in jail for over a year after being convicted in the teacher’s recruitment scam. Younger son Abhay Chautala is steering the party but except for certain pockets, the party’s hold is on wane. In the last two elections, INLD failed to win even a single Lok Sabha seat and this time it is hopeful of a better performance and has high hopes from Hisar. The fourth generation of Devi Lal’s family—Dushyant Chautala, grandson of OP Chautala is pitted here against another dynast, Kuldeep Bishnoi, son of the tallest non-Jat leader of the state, Bhajan Lal. 
With election campaign coming to an end in the state, all eyes are now on polling on April 10. We take a look on the issues and the seats in the state. 

ISSUES

Jat Reservation: No one in Haryana thought that Jats would be declared backward as they are the dominant caste—socially, economically and politically. They control the reins of power with the Chief Minister from the community and also the Leader of Opposition.  However, the Bhupinder Singh Hooda government thought otherwise and took help from UPA in the Centre to declare Jats as OBCs. Expecting to reap rich political dividends, the move, however fizzled out within a few weeks.  The Jats do not know how it will benefit them, if at all. They are still not sure how it will be implemented and the quantum of benefits under OBC quota. So, even though Congress has made it an election issue and hammers the point through, Jat reservation has become a non-issue in the Jat land of the country.

Khaps: Made infamous due to a series of honour killings, every political party seeks their support, most of them covertly and some openly for electoral success. There is no doubt that they influence the voting pattern in the countryside in the well knit society where family and caste play an important role in determining social identity of a person. But it is equally true that the support of around a dozen and half Khaps is divided. While some of them support Congress, others support INLD and there are some within the khaps who are supporting BJP as well, particularly in 2014 elections. A lot of khaps want to be on the winning side this time round and their leaders are exploring options of getting closer to those who they think would be on the winning side. The prominent khaps amongst the Jats keep claiming that they are apolitical in nature but it is an open secret that their leaders openly sympathise and support political parties. One of the most important demands of most of the Khaps is banning of same gotra marriage by making amendments in the Hindu Marriage Act. No party is opposing this. In fact, no leader would utter a word against them and all praise their “social activism”.

Sympathy wave: INLD is trying to create a sympathy wave in favour of their jailed leaders Om Prakash Chautala and Ajay Chautala. An emotional letter purportedly written by the senior Chautala has been distributed by the party all over the state to generate a sympathy wave. The party has been blaming the Congress and its control on the CBI to highlight how its leaders have been targeted. Younger son, Abhay Chautala is trying hard and is touring the entire state to salvage something for the party. He has already declared unconditional support for Narendra Modi and the party is expected to support BJP if it managed to buck the trend of last two Lok Sabha polls and win a seat in the state.

Anti incumbency: Bhupinder Singh Hooda has been in power for two terms as Chief Minister and the state would go to assembly polls in October this year, soon after the Lok Sabha polls. Hooda’s tenure coincided with that of the Congress in the Centre and there is double anti-incumbency in the state. In the 2009 Assembly polls, Congress did not get a majority and was struck at 40 in the 90 member assembly. Political maneuvering and power deals saw the disintegration of HJC and merger of 5 of its members in Congress and support of Independents. Questionable land deals of Robert Vadra, the son-in-law of Congress President Sonia Gandhi and a series of criminal cases against MLAs supporting Hooda, has severely dented the prospects of the party affecting its chances in the polls. 

CONSTITUENCIES

1.     Ambala: Dalits comprise over 7 lakh voters, Punjabi 2.25 lakh and Brahmin 1.38 lakh in the constituency which borders Chandigarh and Himachal Pradesh. After sitting MP Selja got a Rajya Sabha nomination and left the battle before it began, Congress has fielded Raj Kumar Valmiki a political novice. He is pitted against BJP veteran and former MP Rattan Lal Kataria. Little known Kusum Sherwal has been fielded by INLD which many say is an attempt to indirectly help the BJP. Combined with Modi wave, BJP has a clear advantage here. 

2.     Karnal: No particular community has a sway here as Dalits comprise 2.5 lakh voters, Punjabi also 2.5 lakh and Jat 1.87. Two-time MP Arvind Sharma (2004 and 2009) would be contesting for the third time against Ashwini Chopra of BJP, Jaswinder Sandhu of INLD and Maratha Virendra Verma of BSP. Initially, Haryana Janhit Congress was allotted the seat under its poll pact with BJP and it wanted to field Venod Sharma. When his entry was blocked in the HJC by Sushma Swaraj, Kuldeep Bishnoi fielded his brother Chander Mohan. The candidature was withdrawn after a controversy broke out and the seat was then given to BJP as it fielded Chopra, the newspaper baron. Only a Modi wave could see Chopra through in a tough battle. 

 3.     Bhiwani-Mahendragarh:  This is a typical rural constituency with Jat voters around 3.75 lakh and Ahir voters around 2.90 lakhs alongwith 1.44 lakh Brahmins. Sitting MP Shruti Chaudhry, the grand daughter of architect of modern Haryana, Chaudhary Bansi Lal, faces Dharambir Singh of the BJP who switched sides just a day before he got the BJP ticket. Both are Jats. INLD candidate and sitting MLA Rao Bahadur Singh, an Ahir may get advantage in case Jat votes are divided.

4.     Kurukshetra: It was here that the Mahabharata took place but this time the battle is for Lok Sabha. Dalit voters are 3.10 lakh, Jat 2.46 lakh, Punjabi 2.40 and Brahmin 1.24. Two-time MP Naveen Jindal who won in 2004 and 2009 is facing Raj Kumar Saini of BJP and Balbir Saini of INLD. Coal Block allocation scam is an issue which the opponents of Jindal are using against him.

5.     Sonepat: Bordering Delhi, this is a typical Jat dominated seat with the community comprising almost 5 lakh voters. There are around 1.5 lakh Brahmins as well here. Sitting Congress MP Jitender Malik refused to contest fearing anti incumbency, forcing the party to choose sitting MLA from Gohana, Jagbir Malik. His opponents are Ramesh Kaushik of the BJP, a Brahmin, who was earlier two-term MLA of the Congress. Padam Singh Dahiya is the INLD candidate. Pradeep Sangwan, son of BJP veteran and three-term former MP, Kishan Sangwan has revolted after a Congress import was given BJP ticket and is expected to divide the saffron votes. AAP candidate Jai Singh Bawala is also a Jat. Wrong ticket selection may hurt BJP. 

6.     Faridabad: Another seat on the Delhi border, where Jats comprise 2.16 lakh voters, Gujjar 1.84, Brahmin 1.17 and Punjabi 1.10. Sitting MP Avtar Singh Bhadana of Congress, who has won three time faces sitting MLA Krishan Pal Gujjar of BJP and R K Anand of INLD. Anti-incumbency is staring at Bhadana even though he is a veteran and this could give the BJP candidate an outside chance. The INLD candidate is an outsider, a prominent Delhi lawyer, earlier in the Congress.  

7.     Sirsa: This is a Dalit dominated seat with 7.2 lakh voters from the community, followed by Punjabi 3.48 and Jat 3.37 lakh. Sitting MP and Haryana Congress President Ashok Tanwar, a close confidante of Rahul Gandhi, faces party hopper Sushil Indora, now in HJC and Charanjit Singh Rori of INLD. Gandhi addressed a meeting here in support of Tanwar, who also headed the NSUI and IYC earlier. Indora is giving a tough fight to Tanwar who wanted to shift to Ambala initially.  

8.     Rohtak: This is one constituency where the Jat community has a complete sway with 6.25 lakh voters and Congress is almost sure to win it again. Two-time MP Deepender Hooda, though recuperating in Delhi due to spinal injury, would be contesting for the third time from the family bastion. In 2009 he won by 4.45 lakh votes, the highest in the state, BJP has put Om Prakash Dhankar, President of its Kisan Morcha, INLD Shamsher Kharkada and AAP Naveen Jaihind. Deepender may not have much of a fight here.  

9.     Hisar: The only seat where the sitting MP is not from Congress. Kuldeep Bishnoi of HJC won the seat in a bye-election after his father died. It is a Jat dominated constituency with around 5 lakh voters, followed by dalits 3.25 lakh.  Bishnoi of HJC, a non-Jat, is pitted against Dushyant Chautala of INLD, fourth generation of Devi Lal’s family and Sampat Singh of Congress. Yudhvir Khyalia a former IAS officer is AAP candidate from the home town of Kejriwal. Bishnoi is banking on polarisation of non-Jat votes but here Chautala too is quite strong. A tough battle ahead.


10.     Gurgaon: Dominated by Ahir and Meo Muslim voters, both around 2.75 lakh each, sitting MP Rao Inderjit Singh of Congress changed sides on the eve of elections and is now the BJP candidate.  Rao Inderjit has won three times from here and was a minister in UPA I. He faces Rao Dharampal, sitting MLA of the Congress, Zakir Hussain of INLD and the intellectual face of AAP Yogendra Yadav. Inderjeet enjoys a distinct edge. (April 9, 2014) 

   

No comments:

Post a Comment