Amarinder focuses fire on Badals

PUNJAB ELECTIONS

July 27, 2011 11:35:39 PM

Amitabh Shukla | Chandigarh

Punjab Assembly elections may be over six months away but Captain Amarinder Singh’s body language suggests as if he has already won the elections and is on the way of becoming the Chief Minister of Punjab once again.

The President of the Punjab Congress has only abuses and contempt for his rivals and hurls them at the slightest pretext. On the firing line are obviously his Akali Dal rivals - the father son duo of Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal and Deputy Chief Minister Sukhbir Badal.

“He is trying to mislead the people of Punjab…It is a complete fraud with the people of the state,” Singh said at a news conference here on Wednesday, while referring to a slew of urban reforms initiative announced by the Deputy CM at Jalandhar last week.

The Captain is not contemptuous to the Deputy CM alone. Referring to CM Badal’s criticism of Surjeet Singh Barnala and the Rajeev - Longowal pact, he said, “this (criticism) is a reflection on his (Badal’s) character. Badal has only used the events in Punjab to promote himself. He has sacrificed Punjab for personal ends.” The former Chief Minister, who had joined the Akali Dal briefly in the aftermath of Operation Bluestar in 1984, narrated some incidents from the heydays of terrorism to point out the “double character” of the septuagenarian Badal.

Captain’s verbal barbs were also directed at Sukhbir’s wife and MP from Bathinda, Harsimrat Kaur Badal. Asked in a press conference if his son Raninder Singh intended to contest the forthcoming Assembly elections, he said, “no. He (Raninder) wants to contest against… what is her name…”? Then someone prompted that it was Harsimrat. The Captain conveniently forgot it and mispronounced the name, apparently to ridicule the Badal family.

In another instance during the 50-minute long interaction with the media of the city, he attacked Vikramjit Singh Majithia, the brother in law of Sukhbir Badal on a pointed question. “They may bring in sons, daughters, grandchildren, uncles, nephews, Congress will win.”

The Captain also took a jibe at the age of the senior Badal. “My uncle studied with him in college…He is over 90…I don’t know what is his actual age though he claims to be 83,” Amarinder Singh told mediapersons at the Chandigarh Press Club on Wednesday.

Observers here say that with political discourse reaching a low, hitting below the belt has become a norm rather than an exception. The Akali Dal too has been indulging in it. But the new found obsession of the Captain with the Akalis and the Badal family has baffled the political observers here. The Badals have become the only agenda of the Congress in the run-up to the Assembly polls which has so far failed to come out with what it intends to do if and when it comes to power.

http://dailypioneer.com/356449/Amarinder-focuses-fire-on-Badals.html

Battle of Badals heats up political climate

July 23, 2011 10:45:10 PM

Amitabh Shukla | Chandigarh

The Manpreet Singh Badal and the People’s Party of Punjab (PPP) factor finally seems to be hurting the parent party. The admission has come from no other than the Shiromani Akali Dal supremo and Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal himself.

In every political meeting and Sangat Darshan (exercise to meet people and address grievances), the Badal patriarch has something nasty or emotional to say about his nephew Manpreet. This has only intensified in recent weeks even though when Manpreet was expelled from the party, the senior Badal had simply shrugged off the matter as having no political consequence.

For the SAD, it is now clearly a fight against two political enemies. While Congress is obviously the enemy Number one, no one is in any doubt now that Manpreet is the enemy Number two. The SAD fears that if he makes even a slight dent into the traditional vote-bank of the party, the consequences could be alarming. Fighting anti incumbency and a resurgent Congress, SAD simply cannot afford to have any erosion in its rural-farmer-panthic vote bank, assiduously built over the last few decades.

No wonder, in the run-up to the Assembly polls, SAD is targeting both the Congress and PPP of Manpreet. If the PPP issues any statement, SAD retaliates by countering it the same evening or the next day. A senior party functionary says that this is an admission of the fact that you cannot turn a blind eye to PPP any more.

Sample this: An emotional senior Badal says that the death of his wife and Manpreet leaving the parent party hurt him. Manpreet retaliates saying he was expelled and did not leave on his own accord.

-Manpreet says the creation of Punjabi Suba was a mistake. SAD retaliates saying the statement is malicious and misleading.

- The uncle says that Manpreet committed political suicide by leaving his parent party and he did all this at the behest of the Congress terming him as opportunist. The nephew reiterates that he never left the party and was expelled and he only talks about the future well being of the state.

- The PPP chief says wrong policies and mistakes has led Punjab away from the path of progress and development, the SAD retaliates saying the state is marching ahead with progress and prosperity.

The war of words between the SAD and PPP has only intensified in recent weeks. Clearly, SAD is now politically pitted against two outfits and it is not to its liking. “In fact, SAD has provided more credence to the PPP by reacting to it. Manpreet should be left alone. He cannot survive politically beyond the assembly elections,” a party worker said, a sentiment which a lot of SAD sympathizers hold.

Badal, who will perhaps spearhead the party for the last time in 2012 polls, before handing over the baton to his son and Deputy Chief Minister Sukhbir Singh Badal, has spent a lot of time in Gidderbaha, the home turf of Manpreet in the Badals stronghold of the Malwa region recently. He has reached out to the people like never before and indicated in no uncertain terms that Manpreet is an outsider, was some kind of a villain and it was only due to SAD’s patronage that he became the Finance Minister of the state and acquired any stature.

Taking the threat of Manpreet seriously, Badal senior has tried to win over the SAD MLAs who decided to support the former Finance Minister. A case in point is Beas MLA Manjinder Singh Kang who has for all practical purposes now deserted Manpreet to go back to the parent party.

Political observers are closely watching how the Badals versus Badal battle will unfold as the final overs of the political match are played out in the next few months.

http://dailypioneer.com/355456/Battle-of-Badals-heats-up-political-climate.html

Haryana Cong meet held in New Delhi


July 20, 2011 10:55:59 PM

Amitabh Shukla | Chandigarh



With discontent brewing in the Haryana Congress on a range of issues, a meeting of the Coordination committee of the party was held in New Delhi on Wednesday to thrash out the differences and put the ruling party back on the tracks of governance.

As expected, the party officially ruled out any differences amongst the warring leaders. “We mainly discussed the implementation of the flagship programmes of the UPA I and II. This meeting was for better coordination between the party and the government. There are no differences in the party,” All India Congress Committee (AICC) General Secretary in-charge of Haryana, B K Hariprasad told The Pioneer on phone from New Delhi.

However, sources said that there were several demands put forward by the group which is considered opposed to Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda. This included allegations that development work was not balanced in the state.

“The development is skewed. Those who differ with the Chief Minister find that the projects have been shifted to the constituencies of those who are loyal to the CM. In addition, projects are being continuously taken to the Rohtak region, the area represented by Hooda and his son, Deepender Hooda” a party leader said.

Asked about the demands of party leaders that development was not evenly spread out in the state, Hariprasad said, “It is natural for leaders to demand more projects in their areas. We do not see it as a difference.”

Questions were also raised in the meeting about Ministers not being involved in decision making as Cabinet meetings are rarely held, centralization of power in the hands of Hooda and constitution of the two bodies for selection of candidates for various government posts in the state.

This was the first meeting of the coordination committee after Hariprasad took over as the party in-charge of the state from Prithviraj Chavan, who was sent to Maharashtra as the Chief Minister.

Those who attended the meeting included Chief Minister Hooda, Union Minister Shelja, Rajya Sabha MPs Birender Singh and Ram Prakash, PCC President Phool Chand Mullana and Minister in the Haryana government, Captain Ajay Singh Yadav.

The meeting took place in the backdrop of Hooda removing Captain Yadav from the crucial Finance department for opposing the land acquisition policy of the state, particularly agricultural land for industrial projects. As the minister holding the Finance Department is practically considered as Number two in the government, Yadav took umbrage and met party President Sonia Gandhi to apprise her of the developments in the state.

To a query about the land acquisition policy in the state and whether it needs to be modified in view of the opposition by leaders like Shelja and Captain Yadav, Hariprasad said that the law needs to be amended. “The land acquisition law needs to be amended. A Bill will be passed by Parliament to this effect and all the suggestions made by leaders from the state would be incorporated,’ he said.

Ironically, scion of the Gandhi-Nehru family and General Secretary Rahul Gandhi had praised the land acquisition policy of Haryana in his Padyatra to enlist the support of the farmers in western UP. The same policy has been criticised by his party leaders in the state as several farmers’ agitation have been going on, including one in Ambala, the Lok Sabha constituency of Shelja.

Hariprasad said that another agenda for the meeting was nominations to the posts in various Boards and Corporations of the state. He said after getting the list from the state, it would be forwarded to the Congress President Sonia Gandhi for approval.

On the party strategy for the Hissar bye-election, the AICC General Secretary said the Coordination committee discussed the issue but has left the matter to Gandhi. The seat fell vacant following the death of Haryana Janhit Congress leader and MP Bhajan Lal. He said more such meetings would be held in the future for coordination between the party and the government.

http://dailypioneer.com/354686/Haryana-Cong-meet-held-in-New-Delhi.html

Cong, Opp lampoon Rahul praise for Hooda


July 12, 2011 1:17:38 AM

Amitabh Shukla | Chandigarh

Rahul Gandhi hailing Haryana’s land acquisition policy during his much publicised Padyatra in western UP has ruffled quite a few feathers in the state.

His statement praising the state government has not gone down well with farmers who have been sitting on dharna in the state against land acquisition. Several of them do not want to cede even an inch of productive agricultural land for industrial development.

The Congress General Secretary’s praise of Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda’s policy, has also upset the applecart of a few senior Congress leaders of the state who have been quite vocal against land acquisition for industrial projects.

During his protest march in BSP-ruled UP, Gandhi had cited the example of Congress-ruled Haryana, saying “farmers were happy in Haryana and there are no problems there…In Haryana there were no dharnas either as the farmers were paid market rates for their land acquired…”

In fact, farmers of Panjokhra village have been sitting on a fast in front of civil secretariat at Ambala city for last almost two months to protest against the acquisition of their 1852 acres of land for setting up IMT.

“Congress suffers from selective amnesia. As Rahul Gandhi has not visited Haryana recently, he is perhaps not aware of the plight of the farmers here who do not want to sell their land to the government at any cost,” said a Congress leader, who did not want to be named.

Union Minister Shelja has openly voiced her concern against land acquisition in her constituency Ambala for an Industrial Model Township. Similarly Captain Ajay Singh Yadav, Cabinet Minister in the Hooda government, too has practically raised a banner of revolt against such acquisitions. He has been quite vocal on the issue and had even met party President Sonia Gandhi to apprise her of the situation.

After being divested of the crucial Finance Department, Yadav, a six-time MLA said, “I still stand by my earlier objections against the land acquisition policy. Fertile land of the farmers should not be acquired for industrial projects and developed plot should be given to the farmers whose land has been acquired for such projects.”

Interestingly, even though Rahul Gandhi, the scion of the Gandhi-Nehru family, has been praising Hooda, his party’s Yadav has been consistent in his criticism against the land acquisition policy. In fact, he has written letters to Hooda asking him to stop land acquisition of more than 450 acres of productive land of Kapriwas, Malpura, Gujjar Ghatal and Mehaniawas villages for industrial model township at Dharuhera in Rewari for another IMT.

Ironically, all Congress leaders in the state, who are opposed to Hooda in the factional politics of the Congress here, have targeted him only on the issue of land acquisition. Apart from Yadav and the Union Poverty Alleviation Minister Kumari Selja, Congress General Secretary and Rajya Sabha MP Birender Singh too has expressed such sentiments in the past. Selja has written to party President Sonia Gandhi seeking her intervention on the issue.

Hooda, however, defends land acquisitions for industrial purposes. “Industrial development is the only alternative at a time when the land holding of the people is getting depleted and the youth of the State are finding it hard to get employment amid the scarcity of government jobs,” he told a rally in Ambala last month, the constituency of his bitter critic Selja.

After Gandhi hitting out at UP Chief Minister Mayawati and praising Hooda during his padyatra, those opposed to Hooda’s land acquisition policy in the Congress have fallen silent. They preferred not to respond to the issue this time.

The state BJP, however, has hit out at the Congress and Gandhi. State party President Krishan Pal Gurjar said that neither Gandhi nor the central Congress leaders have shown any concern even as the farmers have been agitating in different parts of the state for over a year against land acquisition. Haryana Janhit Congress chief Kuldeep Bishnoi has also criticised Gandhi for “double standards” and ignoring the plight of farmers in Haryana and campaigning only in Uttar Pradesh for political reasons and not concern for the farmers.

http://dailypioneer.com/352568/Cong-Opp-lampoon-Rahul-praise-for-Hooda.html

Babu-neta nexus at zenith as poll nears



July 07, 2011 10:48:45 PM

Amitabh Shukla | Chandigarh

The politicisation of bureaucracy and the bureaucratisation of politics is almost complete in Punjab in the run-up to the state assembly elections. For many in the state, both politics and bureaucracy, which also comprises the police, go hand in hand and there is hardly a dividing line between the two.

With Assembly elections a little over six months away and stakes very high, political parties have roped in the bureaucracy for furthering their agenda while the bureaucrats are courting the political masters to gain a foothold in the rough and unpredictable world of politics.

At least four police officers, some retired, some serving, are eyeing politics as a new career. This includes the Director General of Police P S Gill who is expected to contest from Moga on an Akali Dal ticket. There are many others who are waiting in the wings – willing to put in their papers to contest the Assembly polls if given a party ticket.

Retired IPS officer Mohammad Izhar Alam, who made his mark during the era of militancy, too is expected to put his hat in the ring from Malerkotla Assembly constituency – the only segment in the state where the Muslims have a decisive role in ensuring the victory of a candidate. If nominated, he will contest against Razia Sultana, the wife of his former colleague in the IPS, Mohammad Mustafa, now Additional DGP. Alam officially joined SAD after retirement and was subsequently made Chairman of the Punjab Waqf Board.

Former DGPs Chander Shekhar and SS Virk too are expected to try their hands in politics, both as Congress nominee. Virk, perceived to be very close to Captain Amarinder Singh, was the DGP during the Congress regime and was persecuted by the Vigilance when SAD came to power. He was closely identified with the Congress when he was the DGP and then chargesheeted and accused of “politicking and misuse of official position” when SAD-BJP came to power in 2007.

A similar charge is now being made against the present DGP, P S Gill by both the Congress and the Punjab People’s Party (PPP) headed by Manpreet Singh Badal. Gill will retire in September and can contest the polls, scheduled to be held in February, without any problem. Sources have ruled out any extension being given to him. Moreover, the Election Commission is likely to scuttle any such move and will play a major role in the selection of the next DGP in the state who will take the state to polls.

Not only the police, even the civil servants in the race for contesting the polls. Prominent amongst them is D S Guru, Principal Secretary to Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal and an IAS officer of the 1980 batch. Unlike DGP Gill, the officer will have to put in his papers if he decides to contest the polls.

Captain Amarinder Singh, former CM and PCC President, alleged that some of the officers are “acting like Jathedars” of the Akali Dal and claimed that he had never seen such politicization of bureaucrats in his political career spanning 42 years.

Manpreet Badal’s PPP has submitted a memorandum to the Governor alleging harassment of his workers at the behest of the “politicised” police and bureaucracy. He said the DGP has become a “stakeholder” in subverting the democratic process. The memorandum to the Governor has also accused senior bureaucrats of favouring the ruling dispensation to silence the opposition.

In the deeply divided politics of the state, the fault lines run deep. The state has been swinging one way (SAD) or the other (Congress) for the last over three decades. No wonder the police officers and bureaucracy too swing from one party to the other. A few have permanent allegiance to one party while the remaining prefer to be neutral, knowing well that reprisals and poor postings could follow if “their” political party does not come back to power.

“It requires a delicate balancing act…We have to be on guard all the time so that we are not identified with a particular party,” summed up a senior Punjab official.

http://dailypioneer.com/351456/Babu-neta-nexus-at-zenith-as-poll-nears.html

Old rivals Punjab, Haryana spar over Hansi-Butana canal


July 01, 2011 12:20:31 AM

Amitabh Shukla | Chandigarh


The unusual heavy showers in the region in June and the possibility of early flood have led to a major tug of war between the two old rivals – Punjab and Haryana. This time it is on the issue of a canal wall which Punjab says has the potential to flood its farmland while Haryana maintains that its construction is necessary to prevent its low lying areas from flooding.
Reminiscent of the Satluj-Yamuna Link canal (SYL) of yesteryears, the issue of Hansi-Butana canal threatens to snowball into a major controversy in the poll bound Punjab, ruled by the SAD-BJP combine and Haryana ruled by arch rival, Congress.
The SYL issue was central to the dispute of the two states for decades so much so that it even became an emotional issue in Punjab and during the days of militancy, the extremist leaders often cited it as a “discriminatory factor” against the Centre to mobilise the people.
As elections draw closer, Punjab has raised the tempo and the SAD leaders are again exploiting the sentiments of the farmers alleging that the Congress led central government and the party run Haryana have completely ignored the interests of Punjab and hundreds of farmers are set to face flood in Patiala district due to the construction of a concrete wall on the Hansi-Butana canal on the borders of the two state.
The latest bone of contention between the two states is the 3.75 km concrete wall, built by Haryana on the Hansi-Butana canal. While Haryana insists that it is being built on their side of the border to protect the fields from being submerged every year due to the monsoons, Punjab says that the wall would have severe implications, flooding 20,00 acres of farmland affecting 30 odd villages.
Punjab Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal on Thursday sought the intervention of his Haryana counterpart Bhupinder Singh Hooda to immediately issue instructions to the concerned authorities to stop the work on Hansi-Butana canal. “The canal had been constructed without any technical study on the aspect of likely impact of blockade of sheet flow of flood waters caused by the construction of the embankments on the state of Punjab,” Badal said in a statement. The CM said the work has been undertaken without any concurrence of the Punjab government.
Playing the political card, Punjab Irrigation minister J S Sekhon said that the Centre was supporting the Haryana government and the interests of Punjab have been completely ignored. “This area suffered a lot during the flood last year. Natural flow of water is being obstructed. All political parties in Punjab should unite against this wall and approach the central government,” he said.
Joining issues with his Punjab counterpart, Haryana Irrigation Minister Harmohinder Singh Chatha said, “The issue is being politicised”. He said the hue and cry over the issue was entirely due to the impending elections.
The confrontation between the two states on water is almost as old as the creation of the states itself in 1966, after Haryana was carved out from Punjab. Both being agricultural state, sharing river water became a major issue of confrontation since then.
Earlier this year, Punjab CM Badal announced in the State Assembly that his government would not share “even a single drop” of water with other states. Not to be left behind, Hooda replied back saying that they would not allow anybody to deprive their rights of having waters of Ravi and Beas rivers.
The Haryana Assembly also proposed for a solution to the SYL canal dispute at the earliest, and the operationalisation of Hansi-Butana link (HBL) canal. The state government has also sought intervention of the Centre saying Punjab had flouted the 1981 pact and agreements related to Ravi-Beas Water Treaty Act.
Now with politics coming into play, the Hansi-Butana canal is set to become a major poll issue in Punjab. While the presidential reference on the complicated SYL issue is pending in the apex court for several years now, the latest row on the canal too has reached the Supreme Court even though no orders have been passed as of now. But the two states continue to take sharp barbs at each other for consumption amongst their respective support base.
(July 1. 2011) http://dailypioneer.com/349775/Old-rivals-Punjab-Haryana-spar-over-Hansi-Butana-canal.html

SAD-BJP IN POLL MODE


Amitabh Shukla / Chandigarh


With elections a little over seven months away, the ruling SAD-BJP in Punjab is on a poll mode. Desperate to buck the electoral trend and return back to power again, it has been making a new announcement almost everyday for the last couple of months.

Interestingly, in these announcements, there has been something for every section of the population. There has been a bonanza for the farmers - the largest support base of the Akali Dal. But other section of the population has not been left untouched - be it the voters in the urban areas, those who live in the countryside, professionals like teachers and government employees and even sections like women, students and children.

The latest announcement came on Tuesday with the decision to provide free education to girl students’ upto Class 12, giving bicycles to 1.46 lakh girl students of Class 11 and 12 and furniture for 4000 schools.

Apart from specific schemes targeted at a specific section, the Punjab government also brought in the Right to Service Ordinance, wherein every section can demand delivery of services in a time-bound manner.

It remains to be seen, how many of these announcements, most of them having financial implications, are implemented before the polls. But the ruling combination is making the right noise at the right time as a part of a concerted poll strategy to outsmart its opponents.

Fighting anti-incumbency, a reinvigorated SAD under the presidentship of Sukhbir Singh Badal, who is also the Deputy Chief Minister, is taking the battle to the enemy camp (Congress, headed by Captain Amarinder Singh).

What has given hope to the SAD-BJP combine and is firing its optimism in the run-up to the polls is the repeat performance of some of their allies. Nitish Kumar in Bihar, a long standing partner of the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) like the SAD, romped home successfully on the development agenda.

Moreover, SAD’s partner BJP too has managed to beat anti-incumbency in Madhya Pradesh and Chhatisgarh. Even in neighbouring Haryana, Congress led by Bhupinder Singh Hooda returned back to power, albeit with reduced numbers. But the feat remains unparalleled, giving hope to the ruling alliance in Punjab.

“Though Punjab has not seen the ruling party voted back to power in the recent times, it is not a fait accompli. Politics and elections cannot be predicted like this. We have seen ruling parties coming back to power with improved majority. Bihar is a case in point,” a SAD leader said.

Of late what has given hope to SAD-BJP combine is the belligerent mood amongst the middle class against the menace of corruption at the national level. Even though Anna Hazare and Baba Ramdev are hogging the headlines, Congress is feeling the pinch, both at the state level in Punjab and also across the country.

Sensing the opportunity, Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal and Sukhbir are attacking the Congress everyday on the issue of corruption. Though the BJP too was affected by allegations leading to the resignation of all its ministers in the state, the ruling combine has effectively managed to downplay the issue and it is no longer being discussed and talked about in the political circles as the Hazare and Ramdev whirlwind hit the national conscience.

Political pundits here point out that it is too early to stick one’s neck out at this juncture and be conclusive about the polls. “A lot of water would flow in the Satluj and Beas from now till the elections. A lot of charges and counter charges would be made. But one thing is certain; it is not a cake walk for either of the two rivals, SAD-BJP and the Congress. Both face a tough battle ahead”, summed up a Congress leader.

(The Pioneer, June 22, 2011)

‘Save Bhullar Campaign’ seems to have fizzled out in Punjab


June 19, 2011 6:31:30 PM

Amitabh Shukla | Chandigarh

Three weeks after, the mercy petition of Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar rejected by the President, “Save Bhullar Campaign” seems to have fizzled out in Punjab. Even though the Shiromani Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC) is trying hard to involve its supporters to save the Khalistani militant from the gallows, it has found little support base.

Sensing that there is no forward movement on the issue from either the Akali Dal or the Congress in the State, the SGPC has decided to submit a memorandum to the Punjab Governor Shivraj Patil on Monday. To bring some momentum in the campaign, seemingly, of little interest to the populace at large, it has issued an emotional appeal.

“Prof Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar is on the death row since 8 years, has been in prison for 16 years, after an unfair trial, a split Supreme Court judgement and rejection of mercy plea by President of India,” said the emotional appeal of SGPC which has a photo of Bhullar facing the gallows. It has asked supporters to assemble in Gurdwara Amb in Mohali so that there could be a show of strength on the issue.

The decision of the SGPC to submit a memorandum to the Governor came a day after Germany and European Union opposed the execution of the militant.

Interestingly, on the day when the President rejected the mercy plea, there was hardly any reaction from any political party. It was only later on that some political parties paid the customary lip service to the cause and then forgot the issue once again. Whatever support base which Bhullar had was limited to the cyberspace where expatriates were sending chain-emails and using the social networking sites to build up a cause.

While a section of the Sikh organisations wanted that a resolution should be passed by both the main parties — Akali Dal and Congress — in the State Assembly against the death sentence, the two parties never even thought of it. The one-day special session of the Assembly early this week found no mention of the issue, leave aside a resolution.

Political sources said that the issue has lost its relevance. “Every medicine has an expiry date printed on it. Similarly, such emotions are past their expiry date. We can see some statements here and there. This is merely tokenism in the election year,” a senior Congress leader said.

Another source pointed out that even during the anniversary of “Operation Bluestar” from June 3 to 6, nothing was reported on the Bhullar front and all that happened was at Amritsar where the customary speeches extolling the Sikh militants was made at the Akal Takht. “But this happens every year. There are no political implications of such speeches and they hardly motivate the youngsters who are rather looking for employment opportunities and ways to go abroad,” he said.

Realising that there is no electoral advantage, both Akali Dal and Congress want to keep the issue under wraps even though they too indulge in populism when repeatedly asked about it on record.

Power cuts and community life...



Amitabh Shukla

Long hours of power cuts in my east Delhi colony at the peak of the summer season has brought about a new feeling of community living and sharing. The sharing is more of the woes of each resident who sweats and curses all authorities in the middle of the night.

This is how it all began. There was load shedding and power cuts throughout the day on a Sunday. The poor inverter in my house could not cope with it. It went kaput at 10 in the night. Sweating profusely, I waited for the power to come back. The usual drills like calling the power company too happened. Nothing materialised as they had switched on the answering machine.

I was now in the balcony to take breath in the weak wind which was blowing. The wind was too weak to blow away the heat generated by temperature in the mid 40s in the daytime. It failed to dry the sweat and soon sweat was pouring from my body all over. At 12 midnight, I looked around. Most of the inverters in the colony by that time had given all they could and had silently gone to sleep. People and small children were waiting for the “power gods” to come back. Small children had started crying. The “Power Gods” did not oblige.

The stray dogs had fallen silent and so did the whistles of the watchmen who roam around in the colony in the night. Restless and angry residents started inquiring from each other. People were patrolling the streets, visiting their friends or simply killing time by sitting on the staircase. Some started moving around in their AC cars but gave it up soon. United by a common problem, they asked each other when will power come back. Everybody was clueless. The neighbour, whom I see everyday but had not talked to for 2 years, came to talk about how the colony, city and the country had been betrayed by the politicians.

Soon, it was one a.m. I went up to the roof of my flat to explore the possibility and feasibility of sleeping there on a chair. The mosquitoes sensed my intention and attacked me violently. I gave up the idea. It was here that I noticed that in the nearby park, there was a lot of activity. The screens of the mobile phones were flashing in the night sans any other source of light.

I cam down from my second floor flat and went to the park at 1.30 am. It was full of people who were now praying to God for the supply of electricity. It too didn’t work. For the first time, in the two years I have been living in the colony, I found the park so crowded. We talked to each other, inquired what the other did for a living and developed a camaraderie – something I had never done in the past. An hour passes. Lights came on at 2.30 am. There was a loud war cry as if India had won the Cricket World Cup. As soon as people started to return back, the supply went off again. This led to a desolation, similar to the one when India lost to Bangladesh in the World Cup.

The prayers were finally answered, power came back at 2.45 am. There was another round of celebration and people went to their houses. The power cut had taught them the lesson of dialogue with the neighbour and community living, missing in the urban life.

Post Script: The same problem occurred a day after and the scene was repeated.
(2010)

GRANDFATHER: A TEACHER'S FORGOTTEN LEGACY




Amitabh Shukla


A veteran freedom fighter, the fight of 84-year old Satya Narayan Shukla has started anew. This time his fight and struggle is against illiteracy in his village of Malkauli in the Bagaha sub division of West Champaran district in Bihar.


Shukla started teaching the primarily Scheduled Caste children from 1983 onwards when his responsibility towards his large family was over. “I had to work hard and see to it that my agriculture yielded enough for the sustenance of the entire family. As soon as my responsibilities were over, I took to teaching after realising the rampant illiteracy and inability of the poor labourers to send their children to school,” he says.


He has already made a difference to the lives of around 1500 children whom he has taught in the last twenty years. A few of them are in colleges and most of them in the government schools at present. Some in the earliest batch have opened shops while others have migrated to the cities to earn their livelihoods. Interestingly, the parents of almost all the children whom the freedom fighter taught and now teaches have never been to any school. However, Shukla teaches only till the sixth class and then the children enrol themselves in the local school.

Born in 1919, Shukla joined the freedom movement and was jailed for an year in 1942 for participating in the Quit India Movement. All his four brothers and father too were freedom fighters and went to the British jails for varying periods. When the government of India started giving pensionary benefits to those who fought the British imperialism, Shukla too was one of the recipients. However, he now spends the entire amount of around Rs 4000 a month on teaching the children. As this does not suffice, he adds some of his income from agriculture to the proceeds of education.

“These children are very poor. Unless they have an incentive for education, they would not come to me,” he says. As an incentive, free mid day meal for around 20 children is provided in his house. Moreover, the children get a feast on special occasions like Independence Day, Republic Day and Gandhi Jayanti. “These children do not know about these historic dates and it is our responsibility to make them aware,” says the man in his eighties.

The teaching material - books, slates, copies, pencils and pens - are provided by the septuagenarian himself. Very few children manage to buy these things of their own. “I ask the children to bring these things on their own but if they express their inability, I have to arrange it myself,” he said. He, however, felt that every parent, even if they are extremely poor, can provide for these if they feel that education is as important as the food which they eat for survival and growth.

The rate of literacy in this backward hamlet in the north of Bihar, bordering Uttar Pradesh and Nepal is estimated to be around 40 percent. “Poverty is the main reason for illiteracy,” says the torch-bearer of the new movement. He says that the poor people need more hands to supplement the meagre family income and do not send their children to school. “Government initiative on this front has not worked as the parents do not see any incentive in sending their children to school. This can only happen in the form of mid-day meals and providing them with books and other teaching material,” he says.

For the sceptics, the efforts of Shukla are an exercise in futility. He himself realises that the efforts of one person cannot change the outlook of those around him. “However, at least a beginning has been made and more such efforts would definitely lead to improved awareness and literacy in the region,” he says. According to him, sustained efforts on the part of the authorities and innovative schemes to motivate children and their parents at the grassroots level is the key for improving literacy standards in the backward district and the state.

The scheme of the “Charwaha vidyalays” (school for the children indulging in cow rearing), launched by the Bihar government with much fanfare sometime ago, has failed to take off in this district. None of them were started here and even in the rest of the state, the scheme was quietly shelved after the initial months.

Ranjit, a seven-year old boy and a student in the informal school, said that he learnt the alphabets with Shukla and can now recite the national anthem and read from the books. Savitri, the 13-year old girl and the senior most student, has learnt Hindi, History and helps her parents calculate their income from selling vegetables in the local market. Asked to come before the camera for a group photograph, the 20 odd students first sought time, rushed to their homes and dressed themselves in their best clothes before getting clicked with their teacher.

Asked why the poor do not send their children to the school, Ram Ratan, the father of three kids aged 5, 7 and 8 said that after getting education, the children do not want to do any manual labour. “Here, only manual labour is the means of income for most of us and if we shun this, we would have nothing left for survival,” said the 35-year old father. He, himself, however, sends two of his children to Shukla’s school and the elder one has joined a government school three kms away from the village. “I make it a point to remind my children about the importance of labour so that they do not see it as a contempt when they grown up and start managing their own lives,” Ram Ratan added.

“When we were a part of the movement against the British, out level of motivation was quite high and we were clear about our goal. In this era, spreading literacy and removing ignorance requires a similar movement,” said Shukla. He said the half hearted efforts of the government and opening of schools just for the purpose of statistics won’t help. “Overhauling of the existing system of education is a must to make the future generations literate,” he added.

But has he any plans of increasing the number of students in his school and open new branches in the nearby villages? “Well, I am 84 now and cannot travel much. I have talked to some educated old people in the area to start such schools in their villages. Only one of my acquaintances started the informal school two years ago and he has around ten students,” said Shukla. He said that he is now trying to rope in the younger generation in this effort.

According to Shukla, education at the primary level should recognise the needs of the children and their parents. It cannot be contrary to the social reality of those who send their wards to schools. “We have failed to keep this point of view while randomly opening schools,” he said, adding, “in these government schools in the villages, only those parents send their children who are financially better off”.

He stressed on the need for a new educational policy aimed at those sections who are deprived, do not have any savings or support mechanism and have to work everyday to earn their meals. “Only these sections are deprived of a basic necessity like education and our policies have to be focused on them,” he points out.

For now, Shukla enjoys teaching and wants to spend the rest of his life teaching these poor kids. He does not even go to see his sons and daughters fearing that it would affect the regularity of the studies of his students. “God willing, the fight against illiteracy would succeed sooner than later and the country would be rid of a curse like illiteracy,” sums up the septuagenarian freedom fighter, farmer, social crusader and above all a teacher, the profession by which he wants to be known.


POST SCRIPT: I wrote this in 2005 and wanted to get it published in the newspaper in which I was working then. It could not materialize. This write-up remained hidden in my e-mail for long. My grandfather expired a couple of years after this piece was written. The absence of his physical body pains us but there is another pain - the legacy which he created in teaching has also been lost. I could not gather enough courage to take up this challenge and carry forward the legacy, at least not as of now.